The Original Tea Party


On December 16, we will celebrate the 238th anniversary of the Boston Tea Party.  At the time, however, no one referred to this event as “The Boston Tea-party.”  In fact, it was called many things.  One newspaper referred to it as “the Boston Harbor teapot.”  I think that is as close as it ever came to tea party at the time.

The destruction of tea in Boston Harbor was really the initial salvo upon the power of the crown over the colonies.  Not even the “Boston Massacre” rose to that level.  John Adams defended the British soldiers who were indicted on charges of murder for the events at the massacre and won them acquittal.  He proper pointed out that the soldiers had been put into a position of defending themselves against a mob and their action were well justified.  His cousin, Samuel Adams, of course, vehemently disagreed with him.  That was in 1770.

In 1773 the political atmosphere in Boston and Massachusetts had changed significantly.  The original Townshend Acts, which introduced the tea tax, had been largely reversed by the crown to assuage the colonists.  But the English parliament saw the Massachusetts Bay Colony as a particularly defiant group who were intruding upon English commerce which all of them, to a degree, were involved in.  They had taken aim a Boston in particular by creating a law called “the Boston Port Act” which limited the ability of Massachusetts to trade.  When parliament had required the tax collectors to be English officials the people of Massachusetts had found ways around them.  Certain English laws required goods sold in the provinces to have been made in England.  The Massachusetts citizenry were particularly contemptible of this law and lead the way in the original “Buy American” revolt.  This was particularly felt in the selling of fabric.  The homespun fabrics of local manufacture were literally quite rough compared to the machine made fabric imported from England.  It was because of a Boston merchant selling only English goods over “Made in America” that had brought on the Boston Massacre.

The men who led the attack on the three British cargo ships transporting tea were led by none other than Samuel Adams.  The supposed disguise they used, dressing up as Indians, was a particularly poor job even by their own estimates.  Even more so, immediately after the tea was destroyed, Samuel Adams stood in the pulpit of the Old South Church and recounted the events of that day leaving no doubt that he was the leader.

Americans felt their access to tea was a right and not a privilege and that it should be defended as such in parliament.  It was not.  The people of England paid no tax on their tea.  Conversely, not only were Americans required to buy their tea from English merchants, American ships had been bringing tea to America, they were also required to pay a small duty on it.  To be sure, the duty in itself was not unreasonable nor did it make the tea too costly.  But the fact that their English brethren did not pay a tax infuriated Americans.  By this time Americans were clamoring for a say, a seat, in parliament which they believed they had a constitutional right to as they were as much English citizens as were their brethren in England.  The whole attack on the ships carrying the tea was based on that one simple principle.

The tea cargo itself, in today’s dollars, would be worth well over a million dollars.  The crown simply could not overlook that fact and told the leaders of Massachusetts that the debt was owed to the damaged merchants.  The colonists responded that they did not know who had perpetrated the crime and that it was inherently unfair to put such a burden on all the people of Massachusetts when only a few had committed the crime.  Of course, as I said before, the leaders of Massachusetts were fully aware of exactly who had committed the crime.  Curiously, the names of those involved was never documented and no attempt to pay the debt was ever made.

The incident on that day may have never gained a name except that well after the Revolution members of Boston society still celebrated their afternoons with what they referred to as “high tea,” an old custom first practiced in England.  These events in Boston society became a who’s who in society in the late 18th and early 19th century.  We do not know who, but some in the press started to derisively refer to the “high tea” as “tea parties.”  Someone made the connection between those tea parties and the dumping of the tea and the name stuck.  The “tea party” was never meant to be complimentary.

In 1773 Massachusetts, few people who engaged in that original “tea party” had any thoughts about separating from the English government.  It was only meant to tell parliament that Americans had the right to be heard as a voting group in parliament.  It was supposed to be an attention getter and nothing more.  They were not even looking to have the tea tax reversed, which is why I find it peculiar that today’s Tea Party seems to be all about that.  The group more exemplary of that original “tea party” is the “Occupy Wall Street” group who are not looking for political power but to be heard.  I cannot help but wonder how that had become lost in the translation today.

What the Attack on Pearl Harbor Really Did to America


December 7, 2011 marks the 70th anniversary of the attack on Pearl Harbor by Japan.  Most people see that as America’s entry into World War 2.  That is actually not true, as I will show later.  But just as importantly, the attack changed the complexion of America forever.  It was America’s coming of age in the world, if you will.

Prior to December 7, 1941 America was an isolationist country that had not ever fully participated in a war in Europe or Asia.  You may say, but we were in World War 1, and you would be correct.  But our participation in that war was fairly brief.  Even though we declared war on Germany on April 4, 1917, it was not until the spring of 1918 that the first US troops arrived in Europe.  A little over six months later the war ended, and while the US did sustain substantial casualties, its involvement more hastened a battle weary Germany to the armistice.

The post World War 1 scenario had the US taking a decidedly isolationist role in the world.  US troops strength was greatly reduced, its air service was almost discontinued, and its navy gutted.  Although the US and England had assumed leadership of the oceans, the US largely left such duties to the English.  Although the US doubled its troops strength between 1920 and 1940, those troops were not prepared to fight a war.  While the navy had built some new ships to replace its old ships, as Pearl Harbor illustrated, the majority of the Navy was a fleet of obsolete ships.  All the battleships at Pearl Harbor on that day were of World War 1 heritage or older.  The aircraft carriers that the Japanese had as their highest priority were, to say the least, underwhelming.  On December 7, 1941 the Navy had a total of eight aircraft carriers on its roster which included the first carrier it ever owned.  That carrier, the USS Langley, was sitting in the Philipines and never saw action.  Two of the three remaining carriers were the ones stationed at Peal Harbor.  These ships, the Lexington and the Enterprise, were at sea at the time of the attack.  The USS Saratoga was en route to San Diego.  The rest of the fleet was assigned to Norfolk Virginia.  The Japanese feared the carriers in particular and the reason was for exactly what they did to Pearl Harbor they realized could be visited upon Japan.

To say the least, the US never saw the attack coming, although there had been plenty of warnings.  Not the least of which was by one General William Mitchell who at his own court-martial in 1926 had predicted that the Japanese would attack the US at Pearl Harbor.  US leadership scoffed at the idea citing the close relations the US enjoyed with Japan at the time.   But between that time and 1941 Japanese militarists had taken virtual control of their government and had begun a campaign of imperialism in China and southeast Asia.  It needed the raw materials necessary to maintain a sizable army and navy.  These included oil, iron, and rubber, none of which Japan had within its borders.  After Japan invaded Japan the US cut off oil and scrap metal exports to Japan.  While the US viewed the action as diplomatic, Japan’s leadership viewed it as a virtual act of war.  By 1939 Japan knew it would have to deal with the US in military actions and prepared for that.  Its attack upon Pearl Harbor was an action it had practiced in great detail for well over a year prior, to include finding a port area on its own shores that doubled as a Pearl Harbor look-alike where it performed many bombing runs.

In 1939 when Germany attacked Poland President Roosevelt already knew he would have to fight a war in Europe eventually.  But FDR and his advisors knew very well that the people of the United States were in no mood for a foreign war.  To that end, when he ran for president in 1940 he did so saying he would keep the US out of the war in Europe.  Even though he had already accepted that we would have to fight a war in Europe, neither he, nor anyone else, suspected that the impetus to fight that war would come from Asia.

While FDR knew that any substantial increases in Naval strength would be noticed by the world community, he felt that updating the air service could be done fairly easily.  The truth to this is the fact that only two new aircraft were developed between 1941 and 1945, the P-51 and the B-29.  The entirety of the remaining inventory was in production at the outset of the war.  The Army Air Corps actually had more aircraft than pilots at the outset of the war.

After England and France sustained huge loses at Dunkirk, England requested immediate assistance from the US in the form of troops and material.  Then, as now, the president could not commit troops.  FDR recognized he also could not send ships and other material without getting the wrath of the Axis and the American people.  To circumvent this, FDR entered into a “treaty” with England that became known as the “Lend/Lease Act.”  The act allowed FDR to lend or lease mothballed ships to England.  Once that commenced merchant marines and other cargo carriers supplied England with the aircraft and other materials it needed to sustain the war with Germany.  By mid-1941 the US was in a virtual fighting war with Germany already as German submarines had attacked many of the convoys.  The US Navy had been escorting these convoys and had returned fire.  For all intents and practical purposes we were at war with Germany but since there had been no signficant loses of American lives, FDR could not declare war.

It is not unreasonable to infer that where America was, and is, an immigrant nation, and that a significant portion of the US population were first or second generation immigrants from the warring nations, a substantial portion of Americans might view such a war against their relatives as being undesirable.  The biggest reason, however, was that the average American could not imagine a scenario where Germany would bring the war in Europe to America’s shores.  The US population did not have a stomach for a foreign war as it still had a good memory of how ugly World War 1 had been.

Americans in November 1941 were apparently blissfully unaware of the presence of German submarines patrolling the US Atlantic coast.  The war in Europe was at our doorstep even though it had taken no aggressive action.  Americans may have also been lulled into a false sense of security by the British having sunk Germany two most dangerous warships, its battleships Bismark and Tirpitz.  Germany had no active aircraft carriers and had only one unfinished in a port.  At the time trans-Atlantic flight was confined to small aircraft and all larger aircraft made the trip via Gander Newfoundland or Ireland.  The US did have such capability but this was not something the average American knew.  This fact is shown by the fact that on December 7, 1941, while the attack on Pearl Harbor was underway, a number of B-17s were flying into Pearl Harbor from the US west coast.

The attack on Pearl Harbor was enough to completely change the American attitude of going to war.  The fact that American ships had been sunk and American lives lost was more than enough.  But the Roosevelt administration felt the average American could not understand the extent of the death and damage done at Pearl Harbor so the details of the attack and pictures of the attack were kept from the American public for well over six months, and even then it was judiciously released.  The few pictures that were released were done in the Saturday Evening Post, and other such picture magazines.  FDR got the press to agree to an embargo on information and to censorship.  For the duration of the war all press releases had to be authorized through the War Department.  Few objected.

Now, exactly 70 years after the attack on Pearl Harbor, it can be difficult for us to imagine the American landscape on that day.  America was truly a sleepy country but it leapt into action, and, as Japanese Admiral Yamaguchi, who headed the attack on Pearl Harbor, clairvoyantly said, “I fear we have awakened a sleeping giant.”  American sprang into action and almost overnight industry was converted from making cars and refrigerators to making tanks and aircraft.  America woke up and vowed never to be asleep at the switch ever again.  America built war ships at a mind numbing rate.  At one time Henry Kaiser, who built the “Liberty Ships,” completed a ship in slightly less than five days.  The US took the lead militarily and has never looked back.  Americans have since overcome any urge to revert to isolationism as well.  Pearl Harbor did a lot more than bring the US into the war.